Thursday, September 13, 2012
How Far She Went
I think that the most interesting character/figure in "How Far She Went" is the dog. When the grandmother left for the cemetery she told the dog to stay and it disobeyed, hopping in the back of the truck, barking until he is let in to the main cab. After they reached their destination the dog whined at her hem, but when she picked him up he wriggled and whined, trying to break free from her, "restless as a child." I thought it was interesting that the dog was compared to a child and was described in the same way as the granddaughter. I'm not sure if it's significant, but the dog was ignored when the grandmother took off to go after the motorcyclists and her granddaughter. This seemed to be the beginning of the grandmother choosing her granddaughter over the dog. The pattern continued when she killed the dog to stop his barking. After the grandmother and granddaughter came out from underneath the dock the grandmother rocked the dog like a baby, or a dead child. I think the dog was a symbol of the grandmother's dead daughter, Sylvie. By killing the dog she finally came to peace with the lack of a relationship she had with her daughter and began a new relationship with her granddaughter.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Good connection! If not a direct symbol of Sylvie, the dog is definitely representative of those emotions concerning the grandmother's relationship with Sylvie.
ReplyDeleteSo I hated this story for the fact that the Grandmother killed the dog, but I think your connection between the dead child and the dead dog was awesome. When I read it, I didn't see the symbolism between the two. (Probably because I was distracted by the awfulness and quit paying attention to anything that could be considered literary!)
ReplyDeleteI like how you came up with this connection. I see now how the dog and granddaughter are related to one another and how the grandmother must chose between the two. I also liked how you connected the dead dog to Sylvie, I skipped over that while I was reading that so thank you for pointing that out!
ReplyDeleteThat's awesome! I just noticed that connection, but I was interested in the dog as well while reading this story. It made me super sad when it died :(
ReplyDelete